Pleasant Hill After Dark: The Legend of the Donnell House


By Dr. Christine Grimaldi

First of all , I would like to say that Autisticana is now expanded into Alabama and the Nashville area; as in New York State will always be our homebase with our dedicated team working out of there.


The other night, I went out to research a legend right here in Athens, Alabama — and I did not go alone. I went with our newest member of Autisticana, a superb and extraordinary person with unbelievable photography skills. What she saw through her lens that night, and what her camera caught, is the reason this story is only the beginning.
We stood outside the Donnell House at night. The great white columns were washed in purple light, and a Christmas wreath with a big red bow hung between them. It was beautiful, and it was haunting, all at once. This is a house that has been standing on this hill since the 1840s, and it has seen more of our history than most of us will ever know.
The house they called Pleasant Hill
The Donnell House was first called Pleasant Hill. It was built in the 1840s by the Reverend Robert Donnell, a native of North Carolina, and his second wife, Clara Lindley Donnell. The historical marker at the house dates it to about 1849.
Reverend Donnell was a man on fire for his faith. He was greatly inspired by the Great Spiritual Revival of 1800, and he became a Presbyterian circuit rider — one of the “flaming fires,” so called because of their spiritual intensity. He held the first camp meeting in the settlement that became Huntsville. He started new churches in North Alabama and Tennessee. And he retired as minister of the Athens Cumberland Presbyterian Church. For his service and dedication, the North Alabama Presbytery was named in his honor.
After Reverend Donnell died in 1855, the house and the surrounding land passed to his son, James Webb Smith Donnell, and his family lived here for years. The house later became home to the Athens Male Academy, and then a public school. Today it stands on the campus of Athens Middle School at 601 South Clinton Street, a living history museum on the National Register of Historic Places, opened for guided tours by appointment.
The night the soldiers came
The Donnell House carries a Civil War story that still breaks my heart. During the Sack of Athens in 1862, Union troops under Colonel John Basil Turchin commandeered the house. The Donnell family stayed inside while the soldiers camped on the lawn. Sixteen-year-old Nannie Donnell lay sick in her bed with scarlet fever, kept awake by the soldiers’ carousing and music on the lawn below. Young Nannie died of scarlet fever a short time later.
It is a story of a child, and a family, and a house caught in the middle of a war. And it is where the legend of this house begins.
The legend that never left
The people who care for the Donnell House will tell you that Reverend Donnell never really left. Jacque Reeves, the house’s executive director and the author of Where Spirits Walk, has said that his spirit remains here — that he is still having Bible study, and his mother is still making biscuits for the guests. And Nannie Donnell is thought to be here, too, with playful laughter and the crying of a child heard coming from her former bedroom.
I do not know what you believe about such things. I only know what we felt standing there that night, and what a little phone app said to us.
My new friend was holding up her phone, running a spirit-talk app, and the screen lit up with three words: “Find my ashes.”
We looked at each other. We did not run. We kept photographing. That is what extraordinary people do — they stay, they look closer, and they bring back the truth of what they saw.
The little cabin with its own story
Beside the great house stands a small log cabin, built in the 1830s. A plaque on its wall tells us it was donated to the Donnell House by Don and Ed Horton, sons of Judge James Horton. The cabin was originally part of the Druid’s Grove Plantation, owned by J.N.S. Jones, in Greenbrier, Alabama.
It is a humble little cabin next to a grand house, and it has its own long journey behind it — moved here, piece by piece, from another plantation, from another century. We photographed it, too, in the dark, its old logs glowing in the light.
Why this matters to Autisticana
Autisticana is about showing the world how amazing we all are. It is about giving extraordinary people the work, the platform, and the respect they deserve. Our newest member is exactly that — a person whose eye for photography is unbelievable, who sees beauty and story in the dark where others would only see shadows. She went out with me into the night to research a legend, and she came back with photographs that make the Donnell House feel alive.
That is what we do at Autisticana. We do not sit on the sidelines. We go out, we look, we learn, and we share what we find.
To be continued
This is only the first visit. We stood on the grounds, we stood at the door, and we photographed the house from the outside. But we have not yet been inside.
We will do a follow-up when we can get into the house — and when we do, we will bring you beautiful photography of the Donnell House from the inside, room by room, the way only an extraordinary eye can capture it.
Until then, look at these photographs. Look at the purple light on those old columns, the wreath, the flags, the little cabin, and the sign that reads “Donnell House, Circa 1845.” And remember Nannie, and Reverend Donnell, and all the souls who have passed through Pleasant Hill.
Some houses are just houses. This one is a story that is still being told.

The Donnell House, 601 South Clinton Street, Athens, Alabama, is open for guided tours by appointment. To plan a visit, call 256-232-0743.

We are building our first “Extraordinary People “ Profile now.

Welcoming Miss Lea O’Connor to the team !!

Here is a sneak peak of

Lea O’Connor Photography .

Stay tuned …..

Categories: Inspiring

Dr. Christine Grimaldi

www.fuelholisticenrichmentcenter.com

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder